Searching For The Perfect Pumpkin Beer: Good Gourd From Cigar City Brewing

The Drink: Good Gourd From Cigar City Brewing
Type: Imperial Pumpkin Ale
ABV: 8.5% IBU: 35
Overall Rating: 3.75 Out Of 5 Pints

Since the pumpkin beers started appearing on the shelves, I’ve been searching for the perfect pumpkin beer. I’ve found some good ones this season, but none that have really blown my mind. I was hoping Good Gourd would be the one that I was looking for.

Pours orange in color with notes of buttered pie crust, roasted pumpkin, and a melange of pumpkin pie spices. Medium bodied with flavors of caramel and roasted pumpkin notes and an underpinning of floral hop bitterness that leads into a harmonious blend of pumpkin pie spice and finishes with drying alcohol heat that creates a balance with caramel in the finish.
-Cigar City Description

Good Gourd comes with the standard pumpkin ale ingredients like pumpkin (real, not artificial flavoring), and nutmeg. But they didn’t stop there, they also add three ingredients that were new to me: Ceylon cinnamon, Jamaican all-spice and Zanzibar cloves. I had a feeling that this beer was going to have a lot of flavor.

In my pint glass, it smelled like a pumpkin pie with whip cream. It was hard to miss all of the spices coming from it.

It tasted like a pumpkin pie too, but with a bit of a spicy edge. It was almost an overwhelming pumpkin flavor (a good thing in my my book), then the nutmeg flavor came out, followed by a creamy flavor.

The spices reminded me a lot of their table saison that I had in their tap room earlier this year, but I couldn’t confirm if it was actually based on that beer. I’d even go as far as to call it a delicious pumpkin saison.

Overall, Good Gourd earned a very solid 3.75 on the Passion For The Pint scale. It was very drinkable and good, although not exactly that perfect pumpkin beer that I was looking for. I guess I’ll have to suffer and keep searching.

Fine Print.

About the author /


I'm a former coffee blogger, but I’ve been getting to know some really good craft beers and really getting into home brewing. I couldn’t resist starting this little project called Passion For The Pint. When I’m not blogging about coffee or beer, you can find me exploring New Orleans’ wide range of eateries, rooting for the New York Yankees (don’t hate me, I’m originally from New York), working out to burn off the beer calories or reading about beer.

  • Robert Young Jr.

    In my humble opinion (I know…that means absolutely nothing)…the best pumpkin beer is Punkin Ale by Dogfish Head.  If you can find it…give it a shot and let me know what you think.